Enw gwraig y Tafarnwr yn Nhafarn y Bell oedd Olive Colley,a dywedodd hi yn ei thystiolaeth fod criw o chwech o ddynion wedi dod i’r dafarn y noson cynt , ac roeddynt i gyd yn rhannu cwrw. Roeddent yn "very quiet - they were all sitting together".
Dywedodd fod William Gore wedi syrthio i gysgu, ac ar ôl iddo ddeffro ei fod wedi dweud wrthi fod ei oriawr ar goll...

"...after he woke up he came to me about 4 minutes afterwards and complained that he had lost his watch and chain."
Pan ddaeth y Tafarnwr, William Colley, yn ôl i Dafarn y Bell yn fuan wedyn, rhwystrodd y cwsmeriaid eraill rhag gadael, ac anfonodd am y Sarjant John Arthur.
Gofynnodd y plismon i James Riley fynd gydag ef i orsaf yr heddlu, a dyma ran o’i ddatganiad...

"He came with me and I searched him at the Police Station and I found the watched [watch !] produced in his hip pocket. I told him I charged him with stealing the watch and he said "All right I am left to it now". I then locked him up".
Ewch i’r dudalen nesaf i weld beth ddigwyddodd yn achos yr oriawr gafodd ei dwyn...

Stori amheus James Riley...